| # | Author | Message |
331
| mele
Wed 3/5/2008 9:10p | I loved Brooke's performance tonight. I'm pretty sure I've heard the "Love Is a Battlefield" arrangement before; I really like it.
Man, can Kady sing in tune at all?
Simon loved Amanda's performance but I didn't think it was that good at all. I am really starting to dislike her voice. |
332
| trekkeruss
Wed 3/5/2008 9:59p | 1. Carly
2. Amanda
3. Brooke
In trouble: Kady, Kristy |
333
| sun-n-fun
Thu 3/6/2008 5:51a | My boys insist that danny is a girl... |
334
| imadisneygal
Thu 3/6/2008 6:23a | But seriously, what is up with Amanda's attitude? Is it snarky, or shy...or what? I can't figure it out but I don't like it. She looks thoroughly bored with the whole process as if she's too good to be on American Idol and she's lowering her standards to compete. Anyone else think she has a weird affect? |
335
| amazedncal2
Thu 3/6/2008 6:33a | I agree with trekkeruss' picks. Although as with the boys they are all so different that it's hard to choose. I also thought Asia'h, Ramiele and Saysha (forgive the spelling of the names) did really well too.
Am I forgetting someone?
I didn't know one song at all, Cady's ? and DH glances at me and say's "Queen." I think in the 80's most of the songs I was surrounded by had something to do with Baby Belugas or Rubber Duckys :) |
336
| mele
Thu 3/6/2008 7:18a | I haven't noticed anything negative about Amanda's attitude other than she looks like she's having less and less fun each week. I think she knows she can't win and maybe can't take the criticism.
She looked younger last night, too. Maybe she's wearing less make up? Maybe not.
I'd like to see Kady and Kristy go. (Sorry DAR.) ;-) |
337
| trekkeruss
Thu 3/6/2008 7:23a | I'm not all that into music, so I too didn't know the Queen song that Kady was singing. Regardless, she didn't do well, which for me is kind-of a shame. Like Simon said, she seems like a really fun girl, but her performances are lacking that quality.
I might be wrong about Kristy. She might stay if votes get split between Asia'H and Syeshia. Those two seem to be almost interchangable, especially with both of them tackling Whitney songs last night. |
338
| DAR
Thu 3/6/2008 7:37a | <<and Kristy go. (Sorry DAR.) ;-)>>
I think Kady is gone and either Syesha or Asiah. Kristy might stay just because she brings a country flavor to the proceedings. I don't think she'll make it much further than the next two weeks. And she likes to bark like a dog :)))))
But I think one person that could be a potential final four candidate is Brooke. She has been fantastic the last few weeks. |
339
| trekkeruss
Thu 3/6/2008 8:07a | I really *really* like Brooke (too bad she is married!) The thing I wonder though: can pull out the glory note? Her understated approach can only take her so far, at least in the context of AI. |
340
| Dabob2
Thu 3/6/2008 8:26a | <Well, you guys called it right!
Amanda sang Joan Jett.>
Did she really? Cool! I missed it last night (had my own gig, actually). What did she sing? |
