| # | Author | Message |
461
| amazedncal2
Fri 4/11/2008 7:46a | Whoa! That was really mean how it was announced. Not only what DAR said but sending everyone to the couch and then the last 3 standing there like deer in the headlights with the cameras rolling. I noticed they saved Kristy (usually in the bottom 3) for the last to go to the couch.
I think everyone was kind of stunned. I think Michael Johns took it well. Now I'm left wondering if Brooke will somehow make it to her sisters wedding :) |
462
| Jim in Merced CA
Fri 4/11/2008 8:25a | <Now I'm left wondering if Brooke will somehow make it to her sisters wedding :)>
I'm just sick about that! :) |
463
| DAR
Fri 4/11/2008 8:38a | <<I noticed they saved Kristy (usually in the bottom 3) for the last to go to the couch. >>
This is the one week where I would have been shocked if she was in the bottom three.
|
464
| amazedncal2
Fri 4/11/2008 9:15a | Exactly DAR, they kept Kristy hanging until the last minute. I guess they do this all the time, it just seemed extra snarky last night.
LOL Jim! |
465
| sun-n-fun
Fri 4/11/2008 11:59a | I didn't think Michael would win anyway, but Kristy and Jason should have left before him. Even Carly - I am not a fan of hers. |
466
| ecdc
Fri 4/11/2008 12:54p | Yeah, that was seriously cold how Seacrest said, "Last year, we didn't send anybody home on Idol Gives Back. This year.......you're outta here!"
I'm sure it was the producer's idea and it's too bad Seacrest didn't tell them to go to hell. |
467
| DAR
Fri 4/11/2008 1:13p | I don't know if you've ever seen Knocked Up, Seacrest can be pretty ruthless ;) |
468
| mater4
Fri 4/11/2008 9:08p | WOW is all I can say about last night. Ryan Seacrest is horrible for the way he announced Michael Johns departure. He always seemed like an arrogant jerk and that confirmed it for me. Even if it was a producer that told him to do that he has enough weight to take a stand with what he says on tv. |
469
| mele
Tue 4/15/2008 8:33p | I have never willingly listened to an hour of Mariah Carey songs before. |
470
| DAR
Tue 4/15/2008 9:03p | <<Even if it was a producer that told him to do that he has enough weight to take a stand with what he says on tv. >>
Right and risk losing his job. He could have done it better no doubt, but what else could he do.
As for tonight well let me say that the Cooks impressed me. |
