| # | Author | Message |
501
| mele
Wed 4/23/2008 10:46a | I agree, sun. She made a point of saying she had never forgotten the words before. Actually, I think she sort of interrupted Ryan or one of the judges, insisting on pointing that out. She seems to be a bit argumentative or vain lately.
I am starting to really dislike her. |
502
| trekkeruss
Wed 4/23/2008 10:51a | It was the first time she had to start over because she forgot the lyrics; I believe the previous time she stopped was because she was flubbed a note. |
503
| mele
Wed 4/23/2008 10:55a | I realize that but it's the 2nd time she's had to start over. No one else on the show does that. It's just not professional. If everyone on AI restarted their song because they flubbed a note, the show would be 3 times as long. |
504
| sun-n-fun
Wed 4/23/2008 11:06a | ^^ I agree but what she lacks in professionalism she make up in having to have the last word!!! UGH! She is driving me crazy lately |
505
| topdisneymom
Wed 4/23/2008 11:19a | I agree with you, sun-in-fun, she needs to quit talking during the judging. I need to stop voting for her just because I like her as a person. It is not a popularity contest but a singing contest. That must be why Jason is still in the running. People must be voting for him because they like him. Next week I am going to vote for the person who does the best. |
506
| RoadTrip
Wed 4/23/2008 12:13p | I have no idea how Brooke has lasted so long. Johns, Chikezie, and even Overmyer were all better than her.
Blame it on women. My wife thinks Brooke is "nice". Why on earth do women always vote for nice??
LOL
|
507
| trekkeruss
Wed 4/23/2008 12:54p | I am not a woman and I like Brooke. I think she is "nice." LOL.
I like her voice. It's not the best or biggest, and she's messed up a couple of times. But I don't really care that she's not professional or polished, because she isn't a professional. Anyway, I'd like her to stick around a little while longer but if she goes, no worries. She isn't going to win anyway. As long as Kristy Yamaguchi wins DWTS, I don't care too much about what happens on Idol. LOL. |
508
| mater4
Wed 4/23/2008 12:58p | I predict the bottom 2 will be Brooke and Jason. Jason was very hard to listen to and I almost turned the sound off so I hope he goes home. I really can't stand to look at that dumb expression he makes with his face. |
509
| JazzCat
Wed 4/23/2008 4:35p | Mater, I DID turn the sound down. I just couldn't tolerate him last night. Brooke was awful too.
David Cook and Syeshah (or however her name is spelled) were the best. |
510
| amazedncal2
Wed 4/23/2008 8:10p | DH and I are still chuckling about Jason saying he didn't know the song was sung by a cat :) I almost fell off the couch laughing.
Carly and Syesha (sp) were my favorites last night. I didn't care for David Cooks song so I knew the judges would love it.
I also think Brooke is nice :) I think Jason is going home, even though I think he's nice too :) |
