| # | Author | Message |
521
| amazedncal2
Thu 4/24/2008 8:08p | Cripes, DH pointed out that I was getting Neil Young and Neil Diamond mixed up :)
Sorry.
I can probably stand Neil Diamond songs for one night. He looks absolutely creepy in his glittering vest on those darned commercials though. I hope he doesn't wear the vest :) No "Sweet Caroline" though please.
|
522
| sun-n-fun
Mon 4/28/2008 8:05a | I didn't wasnt Carly to make it to the end but Jason and Brooke should have gone first. As a woman I think Brooke is annoying. I don't even find her nice, just sickingfly sweet to the point of being phoney and somewhat arragant. I hate the way she talks back although did like that she admitted it! |
523
| DAR
Wed 4/30/2008 4:35a | Okay I thought the first half was a weak showing by everyone. Mr. Diamond deserves better than that. The second half I liked David Cook and Brooke the best. |
524
| SFH
Wed 4/30/2008 7:00a | Paula reading her lines ahead of time was the best part of last night's show. |
525
| Tinkerbell819
Wed 4/30/2008 7:21a | Yes, that was classic Paula last night! LOL
|
526
| TXDISNEYNERD
Wed 4/30/2008 11:54a | Yes Paula was um.. interesting last night. I think the bottom two has got to be Brooke and Jason. Either one can go home IMHO. David Cook is the best.
Does Jason remind anyone else of Lord of the Rings? For some reason, I can't look at him without thinking he is a long lost relative of the elves and he is going to pull out his bow and arrow at any moment now. |
527
| Rsey103
Wed 4/30/2008 2:54p | >>Paula reading her lines ahead of time was the best part of last night's show.<<
Their song critiques are written by them or for them before the show???
And why didn't the panel comment on the first songs last night?
Is Jason's hair real? |
528
| imadisneygal
Wed 4/30/2008 6:33p | ^^^
1. No, they're usually off the cuff.
2. Time constraints because each contestant sang two songs last night. They commented all at once between the first and second songs.
3. Yes, it is. :) |
529
| Inspector 57
Wed 4/30/2008 8:41p | Ironically, the loser's song sounded 300% better when performed tonight than last night's version, IMHO. |
530
| sun-n-fun
Thu 5/1/2008 5:32a | I was sooooo glad to see Brooke leave.
Jason must have a huge fan base. Friends from home and a slew of girls (apparently even though I do not see the appeal). I can't figure out how he was not in the bottom 2 or 3. |
